12-Pk 2.75-Oz My-T-Fine Lemon Pudding Mix & Pie Filling

desynergy

Jul 22, 2026 11:13 AM

4.5K Comments

Joined Jul 2012

desynergyJul 22, 2026 11:13 AM

4.5K Comments

Hmm... never heard of them before. Doesnt look like any Walmarts in the KC area sells any of the single packs. I'll give them a try.

caffeinated_one

Jul 22, 2026 11:48 AM

2.8K Comments

Joined May 2010

caffeinated_oneJul 22, 2026 11:48 AM

2.8K Comments

Quote from desynergy

:

Hmm... never heard of them before. Doesnt look like any Walmarts in the KC area sells any of the single packs. I'll give them a try.

Same, but it is a clearance, so if it's good you'll have to find another source. It's just lemon pie filling. Lemon pie filling is pretty versatile for a lot of Summertime desserts, so I'm in.

RobinR99

Jul 22, 2026 1:16 PM

757 Comments

Joined Jun 2003

RobinR99Jul 22, 2026 1:16 PM

757 Comments

Quote from desynergy

:

Hmm... never heard of them before. Doesnt look like any Walmarts in the KC area sells any of the single packs. I'll give them a try.

this is a brand I saw in NYC forever. It is good. My mom bought it and I am 73, so it has been around and successful for a long time.

1

RobinR99

Jul 22, 2026 1:20 PM

757 Comments

Joined Jun 2003

RobinR99Jul 22, 2026 1:20 PM

757 Comments

I bought 2 boxes of chocolate pudding for 87 cents each, good for me! These are all cook and serve, not instant. love it

1

desynergy

Jul 22, 2026 1:45 PM

4.5K Comments

Joined Jul 2012

desynergyJul 22, 2026 1:45 PM

4.5K Comments

Quote from RobinR99

:

this is a brand I saw in NYC forever. It is good. My mom bought it and I am 73, so it has been around and successful for a long time.

That's what I figured, they were a regional brand. It's like Nehi soda pop. Cant hardly find it anywhere around KC, but down south, it's everywhere.

2

StrongLinen2107

Jul 23, 2026 1:01 AM

109 Comments

Joined Jun 2024

StrongLinen2107Jul 23, 2026 1:01 AM

109 Comments

Quote from RobinR99

:

this is a brand I saw in NYC forever. It is good. My mom bought it and I am 73, so it has been around and successful for a long time.

Same here. It's in every grocery store in Brooklyn

2

caffeinated_one

Yesterday 11:26 AM

2.8K Comments

Joined May 2010

caffeinated_oneYesterday 11:26 AM

2.8K Comments

Just FYI, you don't just add water. The instructions for making pie filling or "pudding" are to add 1/2" cup sugar and 2 egg yolks, along with the 2 cups of water needed. I tried it without adding sugar and egg yolks and it's OK, but it isn't going to win any prizes as a lemon pie filling.

It didn't taste very good warm, so I let it chill overnight. That made it taste better, but the texture was off without the added sugar and egg yolks, it was almost "jello", pretty firm. It probably is good if made as instructed, I don't know about adding more sugar though, it was sweet enough to me, but that probably improves the texture as well.

1

buick66

Yesterday 5:57 PM

2.7K Comments

Joined Jun 2009

buick66Yesterday 5:57 PM

2.7K Comments

Quote from desynergy

:

That's what I figured, they were a regional brand. It's like Nehi soda pop. Cant hardly find it anywhere around KC, but down south, it's everywhere.

I remember this brand from my childhood in SoCal. I am 70 plus. However, I don't need any pudding/pie filling now.

grannymike

Yesterday 6:41 PM

289 Comments

Joined Dec 2004

grannymikeYesterday 6:41 PM

289 Comments

Quote from caffeinated_one

:

Just FYI, you don't just add water. The instructions for making pie filling or "pudding" are to add 1/2" cup sugar and 2 egg yolks, along with the 2 cups of water needed. I tried it without adding sugar and egg yolks and it's OK, but it isn't going to win any prizes as a lemon pie filling. It didn't taste very good warm, so I let it chill overnight. That made it taste better, but the texture was off without the added sugar and egg yolks, it was almost "jello", pretty firm. It probably is good if made as instructed, I don't know about adding more sugar though, it was sweet enough to me, but that probably improves the texture as well.

Thanks for the information as to how to use it. While it sounds iffy, I'm still going to give it a try.

Pyrrhhonn

Yesterday 7:11 PM

54 Comments

Joined Nov 2025

PyrrhhonnYesterday 7:11 PM

54 Comments

I am interested based on the name alone

caffeinated_one

Yesterday 8:48 PM

2.8K Comments

Joined May 2010

caffeinated_oneYesterday 8:48 PM

2.8K Comments

Quote from grannymike

:

Thanks for the information as to how to use it. While it sounds iffy, I'm still going to give it a try.

I think you'll like it. Since I only used water I got what I got. I later took a stick blender after it was solid and I was able to make it very smooth and creamy in texture. If you make it per the instructions it will be as good as any commercial lemon pie filling out there.

grannymike

Yesterday 8:56 PM

289 Comments

Joined Dec 2004

grannymikeYesterday 8:56 PM

289 Comments

Quote from caffeinated_one

:

I think you'll like it. Since I only used water I got what I got. I later took a stick blender after it was solid and I was able to make it very smooth and creamy in texture. If you make it per the instructions it will be as good as any commercial lemon pie filling out there.

Thanks for even more information. I appreciate it very much.

1

mytime007

Today 12:23 AM

23 Comments

Joined Oct 2018

mytime007Today 12:23 AM

23 Comments

this brand is in dollar general, seen it there after i picked up a case of the honey cornbread on amazon

Rating:	(4.6 out of 5 stars)
Reviews:	459 Walmart Reviews
Product Description:	My T Fine Lemon Pudding & Pie Filling, 2.75 oz - Case of 12 My T Fine Lemon Pudding & Pie Filling, 2.75 oz - Case of 12
Model Number:	0007239233012
Product SKU:	980929231

12-Pk 2.75-Oz My-T-Fine Lemon Pudding Mix & Pie Filling

$5.90

$18

Editor's Notes

Original Post

Editor's Notes

Original Post

Community Voting

Join The Conversation

13 Comments

Join The Conversation

Related Searches

Popular Deals

Trending Deals